Area selectmen oppose gasification plant
Charlotte Boynton
As a result of a meeting held to discuss ways to protect the Sheepscot
River and Back River from "perilous industrial development," the 123
rd
Legislature may have some added resolutions to decide on at their next
session.
Over 40 people met at Bintliff's Ocean Grill last Thursday, October 11,
to discuss how to prevent the proposed gasification plant from being built
on former Maine Yankee property. Announced to Wiscasset selectmen in July,
the plant would be built by National RE/sources of Connecticut, on 400
acres of land near the Back River, which the company purchased from Maine
Yankee, an atomic power plant which closed in 1997. If built, it will be
called the Twin River Energy Center.
Edgecomb selectmen organized the meeting with invitations sent to
neighboring town officials, except for Wiscasset.
Edgecomb Selectman Jo Cameron opened the meeting by saying, "We are
here to discover ways to protect an economic region from massive
industrial development unsuited to our midcoast Maine conditions, and
thereby a threat to us. The big bullet we have to bite is `can a number of
towns in a region work together to prevent or discourage one town from
taking steps that will endanger the region?' "
Two of the Edgecomb selectmen were asked why Wiscasset was not invited
to attend the meeting.
Selectman John Johnson said, "It was nothing personal. The Wiscasset
selectmen had already made up their minds, and we didn't look to change
their minds regarding the gasification plant. Also we didn't think they
should come to the meeting and be hammered. We just felt they didn't need
to be there."
"We didn't want to lock heads with them," Cameron said.
"It was determined that this meeting should be for the towns of the
affected region only, with advisors from the conservation,
environmentalist and traditional industries communities," she said.
Steven Hinchman from the Conservation Law Foundation told the group
that Maine is not the place of choice for such a plant.
Besides the environmental problems, he said the negative aspects of the
project include: fewer homebuyers in the Wiscasset area, drastically
lowered property values; discouragement of tourism, and ironically,
increased taxes on properties outside the immediate area of the plant.
Hinchman also expressed doubt that the coastal rail lines will have the
industrial strength to haul the many tons of raw coal required. He told
the group that State Representative Bruce MacDonald (District 61) will
soon be introducing legislation requiring any coal gasification project in
Maine to comply with a 90 percent clean product standard.
According to Hinchman, this legislation would effectively prohibit the
gasification project from being developed, unless the company can pipe
"the noxious byproducts to sites where deep burial is possible, like
upstate New York."
Stott Carleton reviewed the project from a working lobsterman'
perspective. He explained the difficulties a barge captain would have
coming through Hell's Gate, and the Snake Twist area around the northern
end of Westport Island and down to Mason Station under the Westport Island
Bridge.
He also spoke about the prevailing winds that flow form the southwest
to the northeast, carrying air pollutants over Edgecomb and as far as the
Damariscotta River watershed.
Carleton urged the group to "move extremely fast."
"The Environmental Protection Agency has set no standards regarding CO2
emissions, and there will be a big rush for permits before such
regulations are imposed. There are only three weeks before the election,"
he said, referring to the November 6 vote in Wiscasset that will change
the height ordinance if voters approve it.
MacDonald advised the group to try many techniques such as resolutions
submitted from the towns select boards, writing to state representatives
and senators, even federal legislators, circulating petitions, and
attending legislative sessions and legislative committee hearings.
At the conclusion of the meeting it was suggested that a joint task
force be formed to research possible impacts of the project. The towns
were advised to put non-binding referendums opposing the Twin River
Project, on their local ballots to put the town on record as to their
position on the issue.
The group agreed they would meet again to develop action plans for
addressing the issue.
According to a written summary of the meeting by Cameron, "there was
some uneasiness expressed" because Twin River's Poe Cilley attended the
meeting.
Asked this week if she had any comments she would like to make, Cilley
sent the following e-mail:
"All the communities in the region should take the time to become
educated and better informed about the energy center. Although the
citizens of Wiscasset will certainly benefit from the project paying 81
percent of their property taxes, there are also tremendous and widespread
benefits for the entire region."
"The energy center will create 200 new full time jobs, lower county
taxes, inject more that $60 million dollars annually into our struggling
regional economy, lower electricity rates, and reduce our dependency on
foreign oil. Make no mistake, these are significant economic benefits, and
more time should have been used to discuss how these benefits would
positively impact the region's businesses and its citizens."
|